The Daily Item, Sunbury, PA


October 23, 2013

Residents skeptical about DEP approval of tire-burner

— ALLENWOOD — More than 90 residents from White Deer Township and surrounding areas crowded into the Warrior Run Fire Department Social Hall on Tuesday night to hear officials from the state’s Department of Environmental Protection explain the process that led to the approval of an air quality permit for a proposed tire-burning plant in the township.

DEP program manager Muhammad Q. Zaman spent 15 minutes explaining that the plans submitted by En-Tire Logistics, of Milton, met all emission requirements and federal and state regulations. Those regulations in large part concern health risks posed by emissions.

“DEP has determined, based on our testing of the ETL plan, that there is no health risk at this point,” Zaman said.

The remark elicited nervous laughter in the audience.

But once the question-and-answer session began, residents clearly were not convinced that the information produced by En-Tire to support its plan was accurate.

Zaman acknowledged that En-Tire would be required to monitor itself.

So why not have an independent party monitor En-Tire’s emissions?

“That isn’t included in the regulations,” said Geoffrey J. Ayers, regional counsel for DEP.

The only way to ensure such oversight, he said, would be to go through a process to change the regulation, thereby holding companies like En-Tire to that new standard.

Over and over again, despite impassioned pleas by citizens, Zaman kept falling back on what he saw as his mission at the meeting: to explain that the data, which concluded that the air quality would be safe.

“But would this project have been approved if it were located near where you live?” a questioner asked.

Pat Parker, of Lewisburg, said, “I am trying hard to be respectful tonight but this is an emotional issue because we live here. A number of us ... I want to really get up and scream because I don’t think you’ve really considered the real effects of pollution this facility could produce.”

The Rev. Leah Schade, of the United in Christ Lutheran Church of Lewisburg, called the data produced by En-Tire and DEP “deeply flawed.”

“Your modeling is based on calculations that are conjecture,” she added.

Then she asked, to great applause, that DEP rescind the permit.

“Take it back,” she said. “Or, at the very least, the public deserves another hearing.”

To which Ayers said this second public meeting, held after a permit decision had already been made, was highly unusual.

“So we do care what you think,” he said.

White Deer Township resident Pete Mackey said: “We are all perplexed why other similar projects around the country were all ultimately shut down and yet this facility plan proceeds. It defies logic.”

At every turn, he continued, “you give the company the benefit of the doubt, but not the public’s health.”

This led to Mackey questioning what toxins might be emitted in the air, including the toxic chemical compound dioxin.

Zaman that there is no acceptable level of dioxins.

“We’re not even talking about negligible amounts,” he said. “It should not be detectable at all.”

And yet, countered Mackey, in every true test of emissions produced by similar facilities around the country — all of which have been shut down — among the pollutants produced was dioxin. To this remark, Zaman had no answer.

The last questioner of the evening was Julee Bertsch, of Lewisburg, who said that the DEP officials were government employees paid by taxpayers.

“You work for us. Help us. Help us defeat this planned project.”

“Well,” Ayers said. “There has recently been an appeal filed questioning the approval. I would suggest you meet with those behind the appeal and carry on with your objections through that process.”

At the end of 90 minutes, everyone was told they had to leave.

A town hall meeting scheduled for immediately after the DEP session had to be canceled, although a group of people decided to meet at the home of a concerned citizen.

The reason for the cancellation of the meeting was apparently because the money to rent the hall had not been received.

Text Only
  • Ritz-Craft Ritz-Craft to hire 60 for Mifflinburg plant

    MIFFLINBURG — Sixty jobs are coming to Mifflinburg as a Ritz-Craft production facility that went dark seven years ago amid the housing downturn will come back on line during the next few months, company officials announced Tuesday.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • Selinsgrove man dies when tractor flips in Chapman Township

    PORT TREVORTON — A 57-year-old Selinsgrove man died Tuesday evening when the farm tractor he was driving overturned and pinned him beneath it, according to Snyder County Coroner Bruce Hummel.

    July 29, 2014

  • VanKirk 'Real hero' of World War II dies

    ATLANTA, Ga. — Theodore “Dutch” VanKirk, the last surviving crew member of the Enola Gay, which dropped the first atomic bomb on Hiroshima, died Monday of natural causes in the retirement home where he lived in Georgia. He was 93.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • Mayor: Rental ban for drug dealers a success

    SUNBURY — A controversial landlord-tenant ordinance passed by the City Council in 2012 has become one of Sunbury’s “better success stories,” Mayor David Persing said Tuesday.

    July 29, 2014

  • Mom cited for allegedly leaving baby in car for 12 minutes

    LEWISBURG — A summary citation carrying a maximum fine of $127.50 was filed Tuesday against a Lewisburg woman accused of leaving her 10-month-old baby unattended for 12 minutes in a car in Union County on July 21.

    July 29, 2014

  • Line Mountain district, teachers $1.2M apart in contract talks

    MANDATA — Separate proposals from the Line Mountain School District and its teachers union are $1.2 million apart and not getting any closer, according to Benjamin L. Pratt, the district’s labor counsel at the CGA Law Firm.

    July 29, 2014

  • Road work: Expect traffic delays on Route 54 near Danville

    RIVERSIDE — Motorists in the Danville-Riverside area are advised that a 2.2-mile micro-surfacing project on Route 54 from Riverside borough to Boyd Station in Northumberland County will begin this afternoon.

    July 29, 2014

  • Blood trail leads to stabbing suspect in Montour County

    DANVILLE — Borough police followed a trail of blood along a sidewalk, up a staircase and down a hallway that led to a moaning woman who they say knifed another woman Sunday night.

    July 29, 2014

  • Spencer_Maria1.jpg Maria Spencer charged with murdering her ex-husband

    SELINSGROVE — On Monday, a little more than two years after Frank Spencer was executed outside his Columbia County home, his former wife and her father were charged in his murder and the attempted homicide of Spencer’s girlfriend.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • Opponents, supporters to discuss clean air rules

    DENVER — Hundreds of people are expected to attend public hearings this week in a handful of cities across the U.S. to tell federal regulators what they think of proposed rules to cut pollution from power plants.

    July 29, 2014

The Daily Marquee

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.