The Daily Item, Sunbury, PA


September 26, 2013

US magistrate recommends dismissal of Bartello allegation

LEWISBURG — SUNBURY — A U.S, magistrate judge is recommending that the Northumberland County Court should handle two remaining allegations included in a civil lawsuit filed by a Sunbury councilman against the city.

However, U.S. Magistrate Judge Thomas M. Blewitt also recommends that Joseph Bartello’s allegation that Sunbury Mayor David Persing initiated an illegal investigation into him in retaliation for speaking out at a public meeting on alleged code issues involving the former Celotex industrial site in Sunbury. A fourth count may be dismissed at Bartello’s request, according to court documents.

All litigants will have an opportunity to make further arguments before a U.S. District Judge reviews the case and issues a final order.

Blewitt recommends sending back to Northumberland County Court Bartello’s claims that Sunbury officials violated the Pennsylvania Sunshine Act. Bartello contends that Persing failed to provide a reasonable opportunity for public comment before taking official action regarding alleged code violations at the former industrial site.

Bartello, who is waging an independent campaign for Sunbury mayor in the November election, also contends that Persing improperly called for a private closed-door meeting to discuss the code issue, violating the Sunshine Law.

Northumberland County Court also would hear Bartello’s allegation that Persing violated the Pennsylvania Third Class City Code and the Pennsylvania Right to Know Law when he initiated an investigation focusing on Bartello and ordered Bartello to surrender his city-issued computer to the police or face prosecution.

The dispute leading to the lawsuit began earlier this year when attorneys for Moran Industries, Watsontown, which operates at the former Celotex site, filed a Right To Know request seeking emails from Bartello’s city-owned laptop computer.

Twelve hours before Bartello surrendered the machine to police under threat of punishment by Persing, the computer’s operating system was changed, a Bloomsburg forensics company reported. In a report, Optimo Digital Forensics said files were destroyed in the process. The company added that it also found pornographic images on Bartello’s computer.

At the time, Bartello was in charge of the city’s code enforcement office and was in a dispute with Moran over alleged code violations.

Attorneys Kymberley Best and Tim Bowers, of Sunbury, who represent Bartello, said Thursday that they were not pleased with the court’s decision and plan to appeal.

“We respectfully disagree with the federal magistrate’s ruling,” Best said. “We do believe that Bartello was speaking as an employee on matters of concern to the citizens of Sunbury, and we intend to file exceptions and test the issue before (U.S. District) Judge Matthew Brann.”

Bartello said he didn’t think the lawsuit would go far.

“They spend $5,000 to smear my political campaign by searching the computer,” Bartello said Thursday. “If Persing wanted to do that, why didn’t he spend his own money? He could have saved the taxpayers $5,000.”

Bartello will take the advice of his attorneys, he said.

The city has spent more than $10,000 to date on the lawsuit, and Councilman Jim Eister said, “That’s a shame.”

“This was a frivolous lawsuit. It’s a shame that we had to even be involved in this just because a councilman was using a city-owned computer for his self pleasure,” Eister said.

“This has cost the taxpayers a lot of money, which could have been used for other projects in the city,” he added. “I am very happy the court realized there was no merit to this. It is a shame this has happened.”

Persing could not be reached for comment.

Text Only
  • Arizona tribe set to prosecute first non-Indian under a new law

    PASCUA YAQUI INDIAN RESERVATION, Ariz. — Tribal police chief Michael Valenzuela drove through darkened desert streets, turned into a Circle K convenience store and pointed to the spot beyond the reservation line where his officers used to take the non-Indian men who battered Indian women.

    April 19, 2014

  • Danville parents hope strike ends quickly

    DANVILLE ““ First-grader Madison Wild was sad she missed school Thursday.

    April 19, 2014

  • Schools ask state to waive 180-day rule

    Three area school districts have asked the Pennsylvania Department of Education to add up their hours instead of their days in order to reach the required amount of instruction time in the school year.

    April 19, 2014

  • Former Bucknell star in NBA playoffs

    ATLANTA — It really hit Mike Muscala a few days ago when he was listening to the Nets’ starting lineup at the Barclays Center in Brooklyn.

    April 19, 2014

  • State: Discard raw milk from Greenfield Dairy

    MIDDLEBURG — Consumers should discard raw milk purchased recently from the Greenfield Dairy of Middleburg, which also has temporarily suspended production after Listeria monocytogenes was discovered in the product following routine testing, the state Department of Agriculture announced today.

    April 18, 2014

  • Penn State police: Three posed nude at Nittany shrine

    STATE COLLEGE — Penn State police say three male students who reportedly posed nude for a photo at the university’s Nittany Lion Shrine face school discipline.

    April 18, 2014

  • State unemployment rate drops to 6 percent in March

    HARRISBURG — Pennsylvania’s jobless rate has continued its steady decline. The state Department of Labor and Industry says unemployment fell two-tenths of a percentage point to 6 percent in March.

    April 18, 2014

  • Report: Pennsylvania forests impacted by drilling

    PITTSBURGH — A small portion of Pennsylvania state forest land has been impacted by shale gas drilling, but many questions remain about how to manage the politically sensitive issue that is opposed by many residents, according to a new report.

    April 18, 2014

  • TRAFFIC ADVISORY: Route 45 east of Montandon

    MONTANDON — A paving project is slowing traffic today on Route 45 east of Montandon.

    April 18, 2014

  • Accident victims remain in critical condition this morning

    DANVILLE - Victims from serious traffic accidents the past two days remain in critical condition this morning at Geisinger Medical Center in Danville.

    April 18, 2014

The Daily Marquee

How do you eat your chocolate Easter bunny?

Feet first
Tail first
Ears first
     View Results
Photo Galleries
The Valley


Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.