The Daily Item, Sunbury, PA


February 7, 2013

Overhaul of rating agencies at a crawl

WASHINGTON — WASHINGTON - The Justice Department’s lawsuit against Standard & Poor’s this week has revived focus on the role of rating agencies in causing the financial crisis. Yet four years after shoddy mortgage investments bearing top grades nearly took down the country’s economy, government attempts to revamp the rating-agency industry have stalled.

Nearly everyone agrees there needs to be an overhaul of the way complex financial products get rated for their riskiness. But attempts to change the system keep running into the same roadblock: The rating agencies, however flawed, have become so crucial to the workings of Wall Street that no one can live without them.

Experts say that the Justice Department lawsuit is not enough — and that the longer the government delays broad solutions, the more vulnerable the economy is to the risks that took it down in 2008.

The lawsuit “may help the government appear to be dealing with the problem and holding the S&P to account, but that isn’t dealing with the core problems,” said Jeffrey Manns, associate professor of law at George Washington University.

The key issue, identified by two major government reports on the crisis, is that rating agencies are paid by the very companies whose products they are grading. Watchdogs argue that the agencies’ dependence on Wall Street means they tend to award better grades to products even if they have reason to doubt their safety.

The Justice Department’s lawsuit centers on this point: Government attorneys allege that S&P deliberately misled investors by giving higher grades to products that it knew had serious problems — out of fear of losing business from banks.

S&P, which has called the lawsuit baseless, said in a statement this week that it has invested about $400 million to improve how it rates securities. This includes rotating analysts assigned to particular banks in order to reduce possible bias. The company argues that it has “long had policies in place to manage potential conflicts of interest.”

The Dodd-Frank financial regulatory law tries to address problems with the rating-agency system in a few ways, though two of the statutes have been stymied.

The most ambitious is an amendment from Sen. Al Franken, D-Minn., that seeks to resolve the conflict-of-interest problem. The amendment asks the Securities and Exchange Commission to consider creating an independent board that would assign rating agencies to structured financial products. Currently banks can pick and choose which agency they want to use.

The SEC released a report on the amendment last year, as mandated by the law, and is organizing a roundtable to discuss it further. The agency has the authority to implement the law but has not done so yet.

“Continued consideration of this issue is one of several steps we are taking to increase transparency, reduce conflicts and promote ratings with integrity,” said John Nester, an SEC spokesman.

Another section of Dodd-Frank would have given investors more power to sue rating agencies if the companies’ assessments turned out to be wrong. Under the law, rating agencies would become liable for any misleading rating included in an SEC filing — much the way lawyers and accountants can be sued if the information they provide is wrong.

But this, too, has not worked as expected.

The rating agencies balked, saying they would no longer rate the securities.

“There was a real threat the markets would grind to a halt,” said Scott Kimpel, a partner at Hunton & Williams and former counsel to SEC Commissioner Troy Paredes.

Companies have been required by law since 2004 to disclose credit ratings of certain complex securities. But in November 2010, the SEC said they would not go after any company that did not disclose ratings of these complex securities. This, in effect, has allowed the rating agencies to skirt the potential for lawsuits from the Dodd-Frank rule.

Dodd-Frank also mandated that rating agencies provide more information in their analysis so investors can have more information to make better decisions. This part has been largely implemented.

Manns, the law professor, said this step was probably the easiest to put in place. “That’s a step for progress,” he said.

The trouble in dealing with the rating firms is that while there is broad consensus about the problems, there is little agreement on how to address them.

“It’s not like there’s a silver bullet sitting out there that we can go and use and solve the problem,” Manns said.


Text Only
  • CORBETT_TomC.jpg Corbett: VanKirk helped to save the world

    Gov. Tom Corbett today issued the following statement on the death of Northumberland County native Theodore “Dutch” VanKirk, the last surviving crew member of the Enola Gay:

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • Afraid of grandson? "Now I am," Amanda Trometter says

    Erick Trometter slept with hunting and butcher knives beside his bed while living with the grandmother he allegedly attacked on the morning he was shot after allegedly pulling a knife on a city police officer.

    July 30, 2014

  • vk1.jpg Ted VanKirk: Seen from above

    The Daily Item is republishing online its spring 2012 interview with Northumberland native Ted “Dutch” VanKirk, the navigator of the Enola Gay, which dropped the first of two atomic bombs on Japan in 1945. The story appeared in Inside Pennsylvania magazine. VanKirk died Monday in Georgia at age 93.

    July 30, 2014 2 Photos

  • vankirk_ted1.jpg “The Japanese were beaten before we even dropped the bomb”

    Compared to the 58 other missions they ran together, the one they were assigned to carry out on Aug. 6, 1945 was easy.
    There would be no return fire, flying conditions were ideal, and if all went according to plan, they would be back to the base in Tinian by nightfall.

    July 30, 2014 2 Photos

  • Ritz-Craft Ritz-Craft to hire 60 for Mifflinburg plant

    MIFFLINBURG — Sixty jobs are coming to Mifflinburg as a Ritz-Craft production facility that went dark seven years ago amid the housing downturn will come back on line during the next few months, company officials announced Tuesday.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • Selinsgrove man dies when tractor flips in Chapman Township

    PORT TREVORTON — A 57-year-old Selinsgrove man died Tuesday evening when the farm tractor he was driving overturned and pinned him beneath it, according to Snyder County Coroner Bruce Hummel.

    July 29, 2014

  • VanKirk 'Real hero' of World War II dies

    ATLANTA, Ga. — Theodore “Dutch” VanKirk, the last surviving crew member of the Enola Gay, which dropped the first atomic bomb on Hiroshima, died Monday of natural causes in the retirement home where he lived in Georgia. He was 93.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • Mayor: Rental ban for drug dealers a success

    SUNBURY — A controversial landlord-tenant ordinance passed by the City Council in 2012 has become one of Sunbury’s “better success stories,” Mayor David Persing said Tuesday.

    July 29, 2014

  • Mom cited for allegedly leaving baby in car for 12 minutes

    LEWISBURG — A summary citation carrying a maximum fine of $127.50 was filed Tuesday against a Lewisburg woman accused of leaving her 10-month-old baby unattended for 12 minutes in a car in Union County on July 21.

    July 29, 2014

  • Line Mountain district, teachers $1.2M apart in contract talks

    MANDATA — Separate proposals from the Line Mountain School District and its teachers union are $1.2 million apart and not getting any closer, according to Benjamin L. Pratt, the district’s labor counsel at the CGA Law Firm.

    July 29, 2014

The Daily Marquee

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.