The Daily Item, Sunbury, PA


October 21, 2012

Interest high in tonight's debate

LEWISBURG — Two Bucknell University professors who specialize in domestic politics don’t expect the foreign policy issues in tonight’s debate to be decisive factors for most of the undecided voters — the domestic state of the nation seems more central to the contest this year.

And yet, interest in this final of three presidential debates is high, said Scott Meinke and Chris Ellis, both of whom teach political science at the university.

“I think it’s fair to say (President Barack) Obama won the third debate, or at the very least, blunted the momentum after (Republican presidential nominee Mitt) Romney earned a pretty convincing win in the first one,” Ellis said.

Obama’s slide in the polls has stopped, and his core supporters feel good again.

For that reason, Ellis said: “I’m not sure that the last debate will be perceived as a ‘rubber match,’ but rather as an independent event. This is the last time we will get to see the candidates debate one another, so if either scores a convincing win, this debate will probably matter much more than the first two.”

Meanwhile, Meinke has found it difficult to distinguish a clear “winner” of any of the debates, since “winning” the debate means different things to different people, he said.

“A candidate may win on policy substance, on style and presentation, or simply on beating the widely held expectations about how he would perform,” Meinke said. “At the first debate, Romney had a particularly strong performance and Obama a weak performance by all three measures. At the second debate, I think Obama did at least as well as Romney in articulating and defending his positions on policy, and he seemed energized by the town-hall format and the give-and-take. Romney’s very assertive debating style, which served him well in the first debate, seemed to play badly at times in the context of the second debate.”

The third presidential debate is taking place with national polling showing an effectively tied race and following a debate that had the candidates closely matched. So Meinke thinks interest will not fall off from the first two presidential debates. Viewers should keep in mind, he said, that the audience for the debates skews toward politically engaged voters who are already committed. “To the extent that truly undecided voters are affected by the debates, the effect is more likely to come through the media discussion in the days after the debate.”

This will be the debate with the least policy interest, Ellis said, just because most voters don’t care about foreign policy all that much.

“Put simply, it’s very rare for Americans to vote based on what’s happening beyond our borders, and that will almost certainly be true this year as well,” he said. Even the situations in Libya and Syria, which are in the news, just aren’t nearly as relevant to most voters as the economy, health care, the deficit or the candidates themselves. But Ellis believes that people will still watch in similar numbers to the first two, because the debate is as much about the interpersonal spectacle as it is the true debating of policy alternatives. And so if one candidate presents himself as being better equipped to address foreign policy challenges, that may matter.

The Romney campaign has been aggressive in questioning the Obama administration’s foreign policy, Ellis said, although there is really less contrast between the candidates’ positions on foreign policy than there is on economics.

“At the second presidential debate and at the vice-presidential debate,” Ellis said, “we saw exchanges over Obama policies in the Middle East, China and elsewhere. The Romney campaign has sought to draw a contrast on these issues rhetorically to suggest a theme of confusion and weakness in Obama’s policies. In the end, though, I think that is a contrast that is more important for committed Romney supporters than for persuadable voters.”

Ellis thinks the difficulty in debating foreign policy for both participants is their basic similarity on so many issues.

Obama campaigned on taking a much different approach to foreign policy than he actually has. And liberals and civil libertarians, and maybe those who gave him the Nobel Peace Prize, are upset with him for that.

“But Romney can’t exploit this perceived flip-flopping, because he agrees with much of what Obama has done,” Ellis said. “So there are lots of foreign policy issues that deserve a serious discussion, the use of unmanned drones, indefinite detention of suspected terrorists and the like that won’t get one, just because there’s so little room between the candidates. I imagine that this debate will be driven mostly by discussions of foreign policy performance. Obama will be arguing that he deserves credit for his foreign policy successes, Osama bin Laden as the main example, and Romney will say Obama deserves blame for his failures —Libya as the main example.”

The Benghazi issue continues to be the most difficult foreign policy question for Obama to answer in the campaign, Meinke said. “I would expect Obama to continue to walk a fine line between pushing back against Republican allegations of scandal and asserting his full commitment to investigating and responding to the attack. But walking that line does risk coming across as evasive, and Romney will probably seize the opportunity, as Paul Ryan did, to link the incident to a broader critique of Obama.”

“I imagine Romney will try to be more hawkish, but only to a point,” Ellis said.

Public appetite for a more aggressive military is pretty limited at this point, and there are lots of issues where it would be tough to credibly out-hawk Obama. In addition, the Republican base isn’t all that interested in foreign policy in this election cycle.

“My guess is that Romney will focus more on Obama’s failure as a leader,” Ellis said, “and, perhaps, his perceived willingness to accommodate foreign leaders above U.S. interests, than any specific, more hawkish policy proposal. Cooperation with the U.N. doesn’t always poll particularly well, so he may hit Obama on his perceived internationalism.”

For most people who are undecided at this point, not voting is probably the most likely option.

At the same time, Ellis said, “Polls usually do a pretty good job of screening out only ‘likely voters’ and reporting those results alone. So there really is a very small portion of the electorate, maybe 2 or 3 percent of the adult population as a whole, that is still persuadable and is also likely to turn out. Aside from mobilizing their bases, that’s a small sliver of the population the candidates are appealing to.”


Text Only
  • Today's Editorial: Child's sensibilities shield bad parents

    Periodically, a decree goes forth from the county seat announcing a special on child support, generally in the form of reducing charges and fines for all those able and willing to make good on some payments now past due.

    July 25, 2014

  • eyebrows.jpg Coming Sunday: Browsing for brows

    As makeup sales soar, four tips to make your eyebrows raise others'. Coming Sunday

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • Budd fundraising run to pass Geisinger

    MILTON — It’s “kickstands up” tomorrow at 12:30 p.m. from LT’s Tavern on Route 405 in Milton where hundreds of motorcycles will take off on a run to raise funds for the Budds, the Ohio family whose matriarch, Sharon, recovers at Geisinger Medical Center from grave injuries suffered in a rock-throwing incident two weeks ago.

    July 25, 2014

  • Attorneys seek $28G more from Line Mountain in wrestling case

    WILLIAMSPORT — The legal fee issue between the Line Mountain School District and the Beattie family, which successfully sued the district to allow seventh-grader Audriana Beattie to participate on the all-male wrestling team, is not over.

    July 24, 2014

  • Driver to police: 'Just shoot me'

    WATSONTOWN — A Turbotville man has been charged with making terroristic threats and disturbing the peace after he allegedly threatened to shoot people in a bar and said he had a weapon.

    July 24, 2014

  • New panel of officers installed by CSIU directors

    MONTANDON — A new executive team was installed at Wednesday night’s Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit meeting, as the terms of the present leadership expired this month. Act 102 of 1970, which first created 29 IUs in Pennsylvania, requires  intermediate unit directors to elect board of director officers annually in July.

    July 24, 2014

  • Geisinger, Highmark deal moving ahead

    DANVILLE — A five-year extension of the contract between Geisinger Health System and Highmark Inc. won’t be affected by a dispute last year over Highmark allegedly undervaluing Geisinger’s health plan and charging certain plan holders more for care at Geisinger facilities.

    July 24, 2014

  • Pickleball players get game on

    SUNBURY — Jan Dockey has been asking the City Council for three months to consider creating a pickleball court.

    July 24, 2014

  • $23 million sweep under way

    After years of finger-pointing and blame, Northumberland County officials have launched an initiative to try to collect $22.8 million in unpaid fines and restitution from what might be 14,000 cases.

    July 24, 2014

  • Mazzeo a finalist for Middletown post

    Former Sunbury police chief Steve Mazzeo is one of three finalists for the same position in a borough about 65 miles away.

    July 24, 2014

The Daily Marquee

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.