The Daily Item, Sunbury, PA


December 13, 2012

Conestoga files federal lawsuit challenging national healthcare mandates

BEAVERTOWN — Conestoga Wood Specialties has filed a federal lawsuit claiming the Affordable Care Act’s birth-control mandate is a violation of the Mennonite business owner’s constitutional rights and “deeply held religious beliefs.”

The Lancaster County-based business with operations in Beavertown and Beaver Springs alleges that the mandate, which requires that most employers offer health insurance that covers birth control, would “be sinful and immoral” to participate in, the lawsuit said.

Conestoga’s mission statement says the company “operates in a professional environment founded upon the highest ethical, moral and Christian principles.”

“(Conestoga) provides health insurance benefits to their employees that omits coverage of abortifacient drugs,” the lawsuit reads. “The plan renews each year on Jan. 1, the next renewal date (being) on Jan. 1, 2013, creating the very real potential for harm to the plantiffs and their sincerely held religious beliefs if forced to include such coverage.”

The lawsuit, filed in the U.S. District Court in Philadelphia, is asking for an injunction delaying the application of the mandate.

The claims are based on the First and Fifth amendments to the U.S. Constitution — freedom of religion and protection against abuse of government authority in a legal procedure, respectively — and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.

Conestoga’s federal lawsuit is the 41st and most recent against portions of Obamacare.

The main issue for Conestoga’s owners — Norman, Norman L. and Anthony Hahn — is the inclusion of abortifacient drugs, such as Plan B, also known as the “morning after pill” and the counseling and education requirements related to these services, said Charles Proctor, the lawyer representing Conestoga in the case.

“This is a direct violation of my clients’ deeply held religious beliefs in the sanctity of human life,” he said.

The penalties for not providing these services would be devastating for the business, Proctor said.

“The penalties are so severe that they could put my client out of business,” he said.

There are 41 lawsuits challenging the birth-control mandate in federal court. Some — including one by the Pittsburgh Catholic diocese — have been tossed out, but Proctor remains confident his clients will be awarded an exemption.

While Lisa Wehr, assistant director of Family Planning Plus in Lewisburg, understands the concerns of religious individuals about providing birth control, there are numerous health benefits provided to women by the medication, she said.

“(Insurance) covers other types of medication, so (birth control) should be something that they cover as well,” she said. “It’s like any other medication.”

Scenarios like having pregnancies too close together can be dangerous for mothers and are preventable with access to birth control, Wehr said.

“I do feel that it’s important for a woman’s health to be able to protect herself,” she said.

However, birth control is more accessible than ever in Pennsylvania, where new programs are making it easier to get affordable contraceptives, Wehr said.

“It’s much better now,” she said.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Text Only
  • 1obamanew.jpg Conflicting rulings on Obamacare

    A federal appeals court has delivered a serious setback to President Barack Obama’s health care law, potentially derailing subsidies for many low- and middle-income people who have bought policies.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • bearden9.jpg Bail reduced for Bearden

    Jasmine Bearden, who was arrested earlier this year on criminal attempted homicide charges for the alleged abuse of her six-week old baby, had her bail reduced in Union County on Tuesday morning.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • US airlines scrap Israel flights

    Two U.S. airlines cancelled all flights to Israel until further notice, after a rocket landed near Tel Aviv’s Ben Gurion Airport.

    July 22, 2014

  • 1flag.jpg Mysterious white flags appear atop Brooklyn Bridge

    Someone has replaced two American flags on the Brooklyn Bridge with mysterious white flags.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • bass22.jpg Mifflinburg honors its national fishing champs

    MIFFLINBURG — More than 50 friends, fans and relatives gathered in front of Mifflinburg Area High School on Monday night to celebrate the homecoming of juniors Nick Osman and Garrett Enders, newly crowned winners of the BASSmasters National High School Championships, held last week in Tennessee.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Newport official succeeds Snook in $94G-a-year post

    Newport School District’s director of educational services is slated to be hired tonight by the Midd-West School Board to fill the vacant director of curricular and instruction position.

    July 22, 2014

  • Report: Retaliation by supervisors common at VA

    A pharmacy supervisor at the VA was placed on leave after complaining about errors and delays in delivering medications to patients at a hospital in Palo Alto, California.

    July 22, 2014

  • $5,000 added for M-W restroom work

    The bill for the Midd-West School District stadium restroom renovations continues to rise to the consternation of at least one board member.

    July 22, 2014

  • Today's editorial: Dubious achievements in press secretary-ism

    Ryan Shucard, press secretary to Valley Congressman Tom Marino since May, recently posted on LinkedIn that he was excited and ready to elevate the congressman’s legislative profile — which Shucard did last weekend (but not in a good way) when he got himself arrested for bringing a pistol into a federal office building.

    July 22, 2014

  • Danville train diver left hospital 4 days before suicide

    DANVILLE — The young man who killed himself by diving under an Iron Heritage Festival passenger train underwent treatment in mental health facilities as recently as four days before his death, according to Montour County Coroner Scott E. Lynn.

    July 22, 2014

The Daily Marquee

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.