The Daily Item, Sunbury, PA


January 30, 2013

DEP says Susquehanna River isn't environmentally impaired

HARRISBURG — Although state officials acknowledge there are serious issues facing smallmouth bass in the Susquehanna River — young-of-year die-offs, lesions on adult bass and inter-sexing of the species — state Department of Environmental Protection Agency Secretary Mike Krancer on Monday refused to call the river impaired.

But another state agency, the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission, disagrees and has been lobbying for years to get the Susquehanna listed as impaired.

It isn’t the first time Krancer and others have rejected calls to put the river on the impaired listing, known as 303(d), which would mean the river would come under certain federal criteria for discharges of pollutants, and studies would be prioritized to determine what is causing disease among the fish. States create new lists every two years. Outcries for the Susquehanna to be so listed were also rejected in April.

Krancer said the data does not exist to list the Susquehanna River as “impaired” under the federal statute. He cited a DEP 2012 Integrated Waters report, a biannual assessment of the state’s rivers and streams required by the federal Clean Water Act.

“Our final report is firmly grounded in sound science, and we expect that EPA will agree with it based on the science presented,” Krancer said. “Based on the science and law, we do not believe that the main stem of Susquehanna River should be proposed as impaired under the Clean Water Act. While we recognize that the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission and others had requested that DEP propose to impair a 98-mile stretch of the Susquehanna River, as we have pointed out on many occasions before, that view is based on very limited, piecemeal data and is not supported by the existing data or the law. But DEP takes the concerns expressed about the Susquehanna very seriously, and we are doing something about it.

The Fish & Boat Commission responded on Tuesday that DEP “has been unwilling to openly reveal the science that guides them” and that discussion between the two agencies “cannot continue unless DEP is forthcoming with their data.”

That’s what bothers Dr. William Yingling, of Freeburg, who has been fishing in and monitoring the river for years.

“The state’s own scientists have conducted studies that indicate a connection between the smallmouth problems and chemical pollution and lists the myriad of chemicals found in the smallmouth bass tissue,” Yingling said. “If the chemicals are in the fish, they are in the water and their effect on living tissues has been shown.”

DEP spokesman Kevin Sunday said the Susquehanna River data cited by Fish and Boat Commission from Dr. Vicki Blazer, fish pathologist with U.S. Geological Survey, had not been made available to his agency as a technical report nor has it been published in a scientific journal. DEP also has not had access to her data, he added.

Sunday said DEP is “going to study, in greater detail and in continued conjunction with Dr. Blazer, the issues she laid out in her data. We are going to do this and make a determination if there is a demonstrated cause and effect between water quality and these issues with the bass.”

Meanwhile, Krancer said his staff would be “working with the Fish and Boat Commission, the Susquehanna River Basin Commission and the U.S. Geological Survey to ensure water quality and aquatic life are being protected in the Susquehanna River. In particular,” he said, “we recognize that there are issues facing smallmouth bass. The actual cause of these issues has not yet been determined or linked to any particular water quality issue, but DEP is dedicated to finding the answer through a disciplined scientific approach.”

“Last summer,” he said, “the agency staff spent 187 combined days on the river collecting hundreds of samples to characterize the water quality in the Susquehanna and its many tributaries. Samples collected included fish, macroinvertebrates, algae, chemistry and data on the river’s dissolved oxygen, pH and temperature.

“Within the Susquehanna River,” Krancer added, “this condition has appeared in a few tributaries and the impact is limited to smallmouth bass.

“Our scientists also tell me that no cause and effect can be established right now between water quality and the tumors and lesions found on adult bass. It is not at this point clear how prevalent the tumors and inter-sex conditions are throughout the river, nor if they are related to the young-of-year die-offs,” Krancer said.

DEP will continue sampling at 30 locations throughout the Susquehanna River basin to develop a comprehensive set of data and continue to look at water quality issues facing the river, such as pesticide runoff, hormone-disrupting compounds and nutrients, such as phosphorus and nitrogen, Krancer said.

Text Only
  • Tawny Dog owners not surprised to learn pooches get jealous

    DANVILLE — Dogs are often considered man’s best friend, but a recent study shows that pooches can get a little green over how much time you spend with other canines.

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • lottery Big lottery payouts pay off for seniors

    HARRISBURG — State lottery officials say less means more for seniors.

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • Donations to Budd family near $60,000

    SHAMOKIN DAM — The Valley continues to give as fundraisers keep forming and donations steadily pour in for the Budd family, of Ohio, while Sharon Budd continues her fight back from drastic injuries suffered when a rock thrown from an Interstate 80 overpass in Union County slammed through the windshield of the family’s vehicle three weeks ago.

    July 30, 2014

  • B-17 fly-over to honor 'Dutch' VanKirk

    NORTHUMBERLAND — A Boeing B-17 Flying Fortress will soar in honor of the late Theodore “Dutch” VanKirk during his graveside services Tuesday morning.

    July 30, 2014

  • dogs31.jpg Is Spike spiteful?

    Dog is often considered man’s best friend, but a recent study shows he may be a little green over how much time you spend with other pooches.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • CORBETT_TomC.jpg Corbett: VanKirk helped to save the world

    Gov. Tom Corbett today issued the following statement on the death of Northumberland County native Theodore “Dutch” VanKirk, the last surviving crew member of the Enola Gay:

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • Afraid of grandson? "Now I am," Amanda Trometter says

    Erick Trometter slept with hunting and butcher knives beside his bed while living with the grandmother he allegedly attacked on the morning he was shot after allegedly pulling a knife on a city police officer.

    July 30, 2014

  • vk1.jpg Ted VanKirk: Seen from above

    The Daily Item is republishing online its spring 2012 interview with Northumberland native Ted “Dutch” VanKirk, the navigator of the Enola Gay, which dropped the first of two atomic bombs on Japan in 1945. The story appeared in Inside Pennsylvania magazine. VanKirk died Monday in Georgia at age 93.

    July 30, 2014 2 Photos

  • vankirk_ted1.jpg “The Japanese were beaten before we even dropped the bomb”

    Compared to the 58 other missions they ran together, the one they were assigned to carry out on Aug. 6, 1945 was easy.
    There would be no return fire, flying conditions were ideal, and if all went according to plan, they would be back to the base in Tinian by nightfall.

    July 30, 2014 2 Photos

  • Ritz-Craft Ritz-Craft to hire 60 for Mifflinburg plant

    MIFFLINBURG — Sixty jobs are coming to Mifflinburg as a Ritz-Craft production facility that went dark seven years ago amid the housing downturn will come back on line during the next few months, company officials announced Tuesday.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

The Daily Marquee

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.