The Defenders season ended on Monday afternoon at Wilkes University with a tough 1-0 loss in 8 innings to Holy Redeemer.
Southern Columbia had three HAC all-stars this season, as pitcher Tomaschik was the lone first team choice.
Shortstop Kirstin Blass joined utility pick Kayla Lavella as second team all-stars.
The Tigers lost in the District 4 semifinals to the Defenders.
Loyalsock coach Tom O'Malley was named Division II Coach of the Year, as the Lancers had six all-stars named, while Chris Ebner of Muncy was the Division III Coach of the Year.
A HAC Division I Coach of the Year was not listed.