Greenwood was issued two cards in the last 10 minutes, including a yellow to Kelsey Keener that gave the Eagles a 5-minute player advantage. The no-goal was scored at the tail end of Keener's penalty.
"I thought, Oh, my gosh. Everything we worked for is gone," said Fleisher.
"When they said it didn't go outside the circle we were like, 'Yay!'" added Osborne.
The Wildcats have four league games remaining, two against teams they beat 5-0 the first time around and two against Juniata, which is winless in TVL play.
"There was no question they understood (the magnitude)," Houser said of his girls. "It was a must-win for (the Eagles, to try to force a TVL playoff game), and, the truth is, it was a must-win for us.
"We wanted to win here."