The Daily Item, Sunbury, PA

Gary Grossman

June 17, 2013

Hard to argue that

It was, once upon a time, the fashion in some newspapers to write scathing editorials. Crusty, cynical, hard-bitten and world-weary is the ironic pose for inexperience.  It produces chiding, demeaning and accusatory comment, usually ending with a call for somebody’s ouster.

Time for Eric Holder to go. That sort of thing.

Three inhibiting experiences have always stood in my way.

I worked for an owner early on who actually had a written newspaper philosophy that cautioned his editors against “becoming a common scold.” Good, direct advice.

The first black woman to run a government department in a community still marked by antebellum characteristics who was the target of a whisper campaign explained her Zen to me by quoting her mother saying, “If you are throwing mud, you are losing ground.” I could not argue with that. Neither can you. Thanks, mom.

Finally, there are all the dogs I have ever known — and there have been many — who naturally divide the world in two — petters and non-petters. Petters, good. Nonpetters, evil.  Dogs have proven to be unerring in their judgment.

I am not good at imparting, but I do like to receive and absorb instructions that defy argument. There was once a newspaper editor named Mel Toadvine who, when speaking of deadlines, said, “Since we have to go some time, why don’t we go on time?”

I never actually met Mel, but his words lived on in the lives of those who heard them — or, in your case, just read them.

“Everybody Smokes in Hell” is the catchy title of a book by John Ridley, which I read. Critics all agreed that the cover, at least, was a grabber, which it was, because it was hard to argue.

Last week, when the world tilted under the news that the National Security Administration was everywhere at all times listening and recording everything (hi, guys!), there was a sudden confusion of ideology and enemies as people slid up and down the spectrum between liberty and security and found themselves on the same side as someone they detest.

In an accidental search for ironclad instruction for this phenomenon, I found Erik Larson’s facebook page. Larson is a greatly skilled one-time newspaperman who researches and writes fantastically researched and detailed books.

You may recognize “Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic and Madness at the Fair That Changed America,” Larson’s account of our first famous serial murderer luring young women to their deaths on the fringes of the great Chicago World’s Fair of 1893.

Larson’s current best seller, “In the Garden of the Beasts: Love, Terror and an American Family in Hitler’s Berlin,” is about ambassador William Dodd and his fetching and romantically adventurous 24-year-old daughter in 1933, the first year Hitler was in power, as Germany’s enthralling transformation gradually turned to terror on a scale no one could have imagined.

In 1994, Larson published a book called “The Naked Consumer” about how our private lives became public commodities through techniques that scooped and translated data into behavior-based marketing. In that, he developed four laws of data, which he recalled on his facebook page after the revelations of recent days. Here they are:

- The First Law (Larson’s Law of Data Coalescence): Data MUST seek and merge with complementary data.

- The Second Law: Data ALWAYS will be used for purposes other than originally intended.

- The Third Law: Data collected about individuals WILL be used to cause harm to one or more members of the group who provided the information or about whom it was collected, be it minor (the aggravation of targeted junkmail) or major (having your bank account emptied by a hacker).

- The Fourth Law: Confidential information is confidential only until someone decides it’s not.

If this is the way data trolling performs — and it is hard to argue that it doesn’t — then regardless of where we find ourselves on the liberty-security ideology grid, we cannot be happy that the NSA is banking everything we do.

According to Larson’s laws of data, what the NSA is gathering and storing is going to be packaged, redirected, harmful and revealed.

 (Bye, guys!)

1
Text Only
Gary Grossman
  • Who throws rocks at cars?

    Although we manufacture and deliver a product, newspapering is a service industry. It is appropriate for people in service to show deference and respect for customers.

    July 20, 2014

  • High noon on Mile Post Road

    A fight that ended with deadly force on Mile Post Road this week outside of Sunbury involved the acting police chief, a respected officer, proud family man and solid community member who often opens local ceremonies with a professional and full-throated rendition of the National Anthem.

    July 13, 2014

  • Good golly, Miss Flouncy

    Miss Flouncy Bighair stood out among the several dozen targets brought down by a trooper’s radar gun, assembled that day in a sterile district court off Route 50 in Talbot County.

    July 6, 2014

  • Preponderance of chaos

    Here is the thing about newspapers: We do not yet know what we will become, only what we can no longer be. That is unnerving at times for people who like routine, pattern, tradition and predictability. And who doesn’t, dagnabbit!

    June 29, 2014

  • Throw the book at ’em

    Where population is too sparse to support art galleries, museums, concert halls and stage plays with ticket sales, public libraries are windows to culture and a center for discussion and engagement for many Pennsylvanians.

    June 23, 2014

  • Doctors following orders

    Once upon a time, I worked in a cubicle farm amid doctors and nurses who greatly admired the Veteran Health Administration for its innovative approach to patient safety.

    June 1, 2014

  • Promises to be kept

    Long after the bugles played and the flags were folded, there was the apology. It was 20 years in coming.

    The man was old, 79. It was time.

    May 25, 2014

  • Things weren't picking up

    I once belonged to a Rotary club that adopted a few miles of busy highway in an anti-litter campaign. Wearing luminous vests and work gloves, we would wander the roadside, wrestling Styrofoam cups from brambles and pitching cans and bottles into giant orange plastic garbage bags.

    May 11, 2014

  • Thirsty boots, no more

    Generally, business people steer clear of the big divide, which is race. The same is true of gender, age, religion, political preference and sexual orientation.
    If there is a sure lose-lose proposition for making a buck in America, it is a headlong dive into our national neuroses. We all realize the “one nation, indivisible” is more of a prayer than an oath and always has been.

    April 27, 2014

  • Tom Corbett's 700 club

    The news department has been researching those 700 jobs for Snyder County, much the way we went looking for the 300-job employer who was floated anonymously for public consumption before the last election in Northumberland County.

    April 7, 2014