The Daily Item, Sunbury, PA


February 20, 2013

Reality show does a number on unemployed

Early in the first episode of the new CBS reality show “The Job,“ after you’ve been told that 12 million Americans are looking for work, an off-screen voice says: “Tonight, everything changes.“

Spoiler alert: Everything does not change.

The show puts together five people who are looking for jobs, though three of them in the first episode already had jobs and were just looking for better ones. The point is, these folks get a chance to earn a “dream job“ (assistant manager at a fancy New York restaurant) by competing against one another and engaging in things that have as much in common with most job interviews as I have with a halibut.

By the end of the first episode, three of the five were given jobs, which I suppose brings the total number of Americans looking for work down to a mere 11,999,997.

This program troubles me on a number of levels, foremost among them the very idea that this country’s woeful unemployment situation has become a suitable subject around which to build a game. Rather than painting an honest picture of the struggles Americans face finding work, it trivializes the situation, creating an environment where qualified people’s fates can be changed only if they can perform well under the klieg lights of a television soundstage.

Through this column, I have met, spoken with and given presentations to hundreds of people who are unemployed. There is nothing trivial about their situations, and nothing that is easily fixed, even if a job comes along.

Consider a few facts from a recently released Economic Policy Institute book, “The State of Working America.“

Americans who lost a full-time job from 2007 to 2009 and were hired into a full- or part-time position in 2010 found their weekly earnings had dropped by 21.8 percent.

The report reads: “This research shows that the average adult worker losing a stable job will see severe earnings reductions that last more than 15 to 20 years compared with what earnings would have been had the job not been lost. One of the reasons for this extended spell of depressed earnings is that the loss of a job is often followed by a lengthy period of employment instability.“

And the harm stretches beyond the worker. The study notes the trickle-down effect on children: “Parental job loss is associated with reduced academic performance and higher rates of grade repetition. Even grimmer: The children of parents who lose work have substantially lower earnings as adults than children from otherwise-similar families that didn’t face job loss.“

This reality is missing from CBS’ show. I contacted the network, and a spokeswoman referred me to the transcript of a news conference the show’s producers had in January. At that time, creator and executive producer Michael Davies said: “I’m proud to say over the course of eight episodes we offered more than 16 jobs to 40 candidates. I believe that the other 24 candidates, by the time this is finished airing, will all receive job offers of their own. And I think, more importantly, to a watching audience, people are going to learn about interviewing, about preparing their resumes, about the things that they need to know. . And I’m really proud of what we have done in the series, producing such an authentic series.“

To the show’s credit, it is sprinkled with job search and interviewing tips, but these are not revolutionary concepts: dress well for an interview; keep your resume to one page. And I’m willing to give the show’s producers the benefit of the doubt that “The Job“ is not simply an opportunistic play on a problem destroying many families.

But even with that, the thinking behind it seems to exist in a bubble, one that also encapsulates many of our political leaders who talk a good fight about solving the unemployment problem then fail to act or act in ways detrimental to job creation.

In March 2011, according to the Economic Policy Institute study, 45.5 percent of out-of-work Americans had been unemployed for more than six months. These are people who deserve help and, above all, respect.

I have had a man in his 50s break down crying over the phone, asking me if I thought he’d ever work again. I have interviewed people who have burned through their retirement savings and stood on the precipice of losing their homes, while trying to buffer their children from the crisis and keep their family together.

Whatever its good intentions, “The Job“ is frivolity at a time when we need good ideas and serious reflection. Unemployment is a painful reality millions of Americans face each day, a reality that has nothing to do with excitement or dream jobs.

It’s about finding work - period. And it sure isn’t something to be set forth for our entertainment.

Rex Huppke writes for the Chicago Tribune. Send him questions by email at or on Twitter RexWorksHere.


Text Only
  • The Color of Money: No easy way to get out of debt

    Many people who are deeply in debt are desperate for a quick fix. They ask the question: What can I do to get out of debt?

    July 21, 2014

  • Watercooler: When to speak up if you see problems down the line

    Q: Our organization has hired a new director. I am one of a number of division heads; above us, there's the associate director, and above him is the director. The associate director is feared and disliked for his duplicity and dictatorial nature, though few have come forward because of his vindictiveness.

    July 18, 2014

  • Career Coach: Bringing a purpose-driven spirit to work

    Increasingly, religious beliefs and practices of employees are becoming more evident in the workplace. Religious diversity and concepts of spirituality are more prevalent in organizational settings.

    July 18, 2014

  • Ask the Mompreneur: It’s best to farm out your payroll

    When my husband and I hired our first employee at our Web development company, we had it easy when it came to doing payroll.

    July 17, 2014

  • Protecting against unnecessary losses

    QUESTION: I run a small bar and grill which is open 7 days a week and have to rely on others for some of the shifts. How can I ensure employees have not become my partners?

    July 17, 2014

  • A checklist for keeping you focused at work

    A quick check of Facebook and next thing you know, a half-hour’s passed. Start chatting with a co-worker and suddenly 20 minutes is gone and the report you were supposed to finish by lunch is late.
    Workplace distractions are everywhere, especially in an age of social media and open-plan offices. In the face of so much temptation, accomplishing what you’re paid to do can be tough.

    July 16, 2014

  • It could be time for a career coach

    Need a little help figuring out your next career move?
    If you’re putting in the hours and still not seeing the rewards, feeling undervalued or simply striving to be more successful, it may be time to hire a career coach.

    July 16, 2014

  • Your Office Coach: Turn to boss for help with disgruntled underling

    QUESTION: When I joined this company a few weeks ago, I discovered that the person who previously held my position is now working for me. “Sarah” obviously resents my presence and frequently says I don’t have the authority to manage her, even though I clearly do. Her negativity has made my job much more difficult.

    July 15, 2014

  • You are not trusted

    If it seems like employers don’t trust employees - well, they don’t.

    July 15, 2014

  • The Color of Money: Beware of loan-modification scammers

    There are some good things going on in the economy these days. Just like temperatures across the country, the stock market has been hot lately. The economy added 288,000 jobs in June. The unemployment rate dropped to 6.1 percent. Yet there are still plenty of Americans who need financial help, especially with their mortgages.

    July 14, 2014

Business Video