The Daily Item, Sunbury, PA


March 12, 2014

The argument against raising minimum wage

Remember, folks, last week’s column focused on those who favor raising the federal minimum wage. This column looks at those opposed. Don’t accuse me of being one-sided - I’m just keeping the two sides separated, so they don’t get in a fight.

If “fairness“ is the buzzword for those seeking to increase the federal minimum wage, the opposition’s preferred term is “blunt instrument.“ That describes how they view the minimum wage as a means of addressing poverty: It’s like chipping away at a problem with a hammer when more precise tools are at hand.

“The minimum wage is just a clumsy anti-poverty program,“ said Allen Sanderson, a senior lecturer in the University of Chicago’s Department of Economics. “I’d rather go after skills and improve skills. I want people to have more command in the workplace, and I want them to have much more than $7.25 an hour. I just don’t want McDonald’s to be the place where they can make that.“

Sanderson and many other economists and public policy experts fear a number of unintended consequences if the minimum wage is raised from its current level to $10.10 per hour, as President Barack Obama has proposed. These include:

-A loss of jobs, as predicted by a recent Congressional Budget Office report, which forecast that total U.S. employment could be reduced by 500,000 jobs.

-An increase in consumer prices, driven by companies offsetting increased labor costs.

-The possibility that a higher minimum wage would attract more experienced workers and keep them in lower-wage jobs longer, blocking young people or people with limited work experience from entry-level jobs.

The job loss argument is supported by many different academic studies, though proponents of boosting the minimum wage offer up studies of their own showing negligible effects on employment.

But a widely cited 2006 study by David Neumark, an economics professor at the University of California-Irvine, and William Wascher, deputy director of research and statistics at the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, examined the literature on this issue and found “the weight of the evidence points to disemployment effects.“

It also found that “minimum wages may harm the least skilled workers more than is suggested by the net disemployment effects estimated in many studies.“

Jonathan Meer, an assistant professor of economics at Texas A&M, in a study released in December looked at how an increase in the minimum wage affects future job creation. The results were not good.

He found that the “minimum wage reduces net job growth, primarily through its effect on job creation“ and that those effects “are most pronounced for younger workers and in industries with a higher proportion of low-wage workers.“

That’s of considerable concern to people like Sanderson and Craig Garthwaite, an assistant professor of management and strategy at Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management.

“That’s troubling, because I think it’s important for people to get into the labor market,“ Garthwaite said. “Even if these aren’t great jobs, they lead to better jobs as your skills improve. That’s the idea. I don’t think we should be doing anything to dissuade people from entering the job market right now.“

The core of the argument here is that the minimum wage is meant to be commensurate with the work skills, education and productivity - at that point in time - of people entering the workforce. The goal, then, is to get in at that wage, develop skills and quickly work your way out of minimum wage and up the pay scale.

Sanderson said a minimum wage of $10.10 per hour might not only attract more qualified workers who would block out less-skilled candidates, it could lure young people out of high school and into jobs that - while low-paying - would be more appealing than ones at the current $7.25 per hour.

“The biggest anti-poverty program we have in the U.S. is getting somebody a job,“ Sanderson said. “If you’re a high school dropout, you may be a lovely human being, but you’re virtually unemployable. How do we make sure that five or 10 years from now, that person has reason to become a bigger part of the economy?“

The better approach, according to minimum wage-increase opponents, is to put money into education and job preparedness plans, which they say have proven success records. And then improve targeted programs like the Earned Income Tax Credit - which subsidizes low-income working families - to directly help the working poor.

“The minimum wage is poorly targeted, and a fair number of beneficiaries of an increase are not going to be people in poverty,“ Garthwaite said. “The minimum wage does go to people in poverty, but it also goes to a large number of people who are second or third earners in their family.“

According to the CBO report, raising the minimum wage would increase the earnings of low-wage workers by $31 billion. But the report also said only 19 percent of that increase would go to “families with earnings below the poverty threshold, whereas 29 percent would accrue to families earning more than three times the poverty threshold.“

In an email, Sanderson wrote: “One would think you could drop money out of a helicopter and poor people would end up with more than 19 percent of it.“

And Garthwaite said: “Broadly, if we decide as a society that we want people to have a minimum level of income, which is perfectly reasonable, there are far more efficient means to do that than a raise in the federal minimum wage.“

That’s all I have room for this week. Next week I’ll analyze the two arguments and see if there’s a way to make sense of it all.

Rex Huppke writes for the Chicago Tribune. Send him questions by email at or on Twitter RexWorksHere.


Text Only
  • How to become a leader

    QUESTION: I’ve just been promoted into a leadership role. I’m excited, but also kind of overwhelmed. What do I need to do to be good at my new job?

    July 24, 2014

  • Balancing Act: How much is your time worth? Consider outsourcing some tasks

    Todd Paton has a booming business getting customers noticed on the Web. One tool he uses is generating online press releases to build brand awareness and create links that will send traffic to a customer’s website. But Paton, owner of Paton Internet Marketing, acknowledges that writing the releases is not his strong suit. Rather than spend his time doing it, he hires out the task.

    July 23, 2014

  • The Color of Money: No easy way to get out of debt

    Many people who are deeply in debt are desperate for a quick fix. They ask the question: What can I do to get out of debt?

    July 21, 2014

  • Watercooler: When to speak up if you see problems down the line

    Q: Our organization has hired a new director. I am one of a number of division heads; above us, there's the associate director, and above him is the director. The associate director is feared and disliked for his duplicity and dictatorial nature, though few have come forward because of his vindictiveness.

    July 18, 2014

  • Career Coach: Bringing a purpose-driven spirit to work

    Increasingly, religious beliefs and practices of employees are becoming more evident in the workplace. Religious diversity and concepts of spirituality are more prevalent in organizational settings.

    July 18, 2014

  • Ask the Mompreneur: It’s best to farm out your payroll

    When my husband and I hired our first employee at our Web development company, we had it easy when it came to doing payroll.

    July 17, 2014

  • Protecting against unnecessary losses

    QUESTION: I run a small bar and grill which is open 7 days a week and have to rely on others for some of the shifts. How can I ensure employees have not become my partners?

    July 17, 2014

  • A checklist for keeping you focused at work

    A quick check of Facebook and next thing you know, a half-hour’s passed. Start chatting with a co-worker and suddenly 20 minutes is gone and the report you were supposed to finish by lunch is late.
    Workplace distractions are everywhere, especially in an age of social media and open-plan offices. In the face of so much temptation, accomplishing what you’re paid to do can be tough.

    July 16, 2014

  • It could be time for a career coach

    Need a little help figuring out your next career move?
    If you’re putting in the hours and still not seeing the rewards, feeling undervalued or simply striving to be more successful, it may be time to hire a career coach.

    July 16, 2014

  • Your Office Coach: Turn to boss for help with disgruntled underling

    QUESTION: When I joined this company a few weeks ago, I discovered that the person who previously held my position is now working for me. “Sarah” obviously resents my presence and frequently says I don’t have the authority to manage her, even though I clearly do. Her negativity has made my job much more difficult.

    July 15, 2014

Business Video